Forum       Forum  Discussions  Dawson's Creek  Who ends up being the biggest celebrity   Previous   Next    10/7/2006 1:13 PM    Icon36 751 posts Who ends up being the biggest celebrity  James, Katie, Josh, and Michelle...when its all said and done who is the greatest of them all??  10/9/2006 2:06 AM    slyn11 1797 posts Katie Holmes is currently a household name...well at least people who have never seen DC know who she is. She was in Batman...I think she wins the biggest star title at this point. Michele Williams is the most acclaimed with the Academy Award nomination and Brokeback. She has been making great role choices and she definitely could see herself in award worthy films again. So in the artistic community Michele is bigger. I think she is moving towards becoming accepted as a true ACTRESS. However, the main populace probably does not know who she is on sight. Joshua Jackson seems to make the tabloids a bit -so if you are into celebrity gossip you will know him. But his career has yet to take off. I think he holds alot of promise. Imagine if he had actually gotten the Batman Begins role...there would have been some amazing chemistry with Katie as the love interest. I would have paid to see that. James has seemingly fallen off the radar. We need to add Kerr to the poll. He is the only one of the Creekers with a steady job. He has a new TV show and previously he was on Charmed for a season. Kerr is definitely working.  10/9/2006 9:42 AM    Icon36 751 posts Hi Slyn11, I agree with most of what you said, except that I would say that Michelle Williams is the biggest star right now. I mean, she did Oprah!!...yes Katie did Oprah first, but Michelle was actually invited to appear by Oprah:) So given her relationship with Heath Ledger and that she has several movies about to come out that she would be considered a bigger star. Katie did Batman, but she hasn't done anything else since. Also, she has become a household name, but but most ppl she is being controlled by Tom Cruise. So I wouldn't give a positive connotation to her celebrity at this point. PS: Josh was also on the short list to play Anakin Skywalker in the Star Wars prequels....I agree, if he landed either role he would be at the top of the list.  10/9/2006 7:17 PM    jimidb 3569 posts Nit picking perhaps, but I agree with Slyn. You asked who was the biggest CELEBRITY not who was the biggest star. I think because of all of her Tom Cruise exploits Katie is EASILY hands down the biggest celebrity. Biggest star? Eventhough Michelle has yet to have an even reasonably successful picture that she "starred" in..............ie one which she was the Leading lady...............I'd still have to say Brokeback mountain makes her the biggest "star."  10/10/2006 1:47 AM    Icon36 751 posts [quote:ace07b8fa6="jimidb"]Nit picking perhaps, but I agree with Slyn. You asked who was the biggest CELEBRITY not who was the biggest star. I think because of all of her Tom Cruise exploits Katie is EASILY hands down the biggest celebrity. Biggest star? Eventhough Michelle has yet to have an even reasonably successful picture that she "starred" in..............ie one which she was the Leading lady...............I'd still have to say Brokeback mountain makes her the biggest "star."[/quote:ace07b8fa6]Did you check the poll question?  Page 1 of 9 123...9Next    Previous   Next     Forum  Discussions  Dawson's Creek  Who ends up being the biggest celebrity